Warning

Info

LSDefine

Simple English definitions for legal terms

political question

Read a random definition: economic-realities test

A quick definition of political question:

A political question is a topic that the Supreme Court decides is not appropriate for them to review because it should be left to the President and Congress to make decisions about. This means that the courts will not get involved in constitutional questions related to these topics and will let the political process handle them instead. The court will usually decide that a matter is a political question for one of two reasons: either the Constitution has already given the decision-making power to other branches of government, or the court decides it is better to stay out of the matter.

A more thorough explanation:

Political question refers to a topic that the Supreme Court considers inappropriate for judicial review. This is because the power to make decisions on such matters should be left to the branches of government that are accountable to the people, such as the President and Congress. Therefore, the courts will not interfere in constitutional questions related to political matters and will leave them to be resolved through the political process.

The courts usually consider a matter to be a political question for two reasons:

  1. The Constitution has already assigned the matter to other non-judicial branches of government for decision-making, and the courts do not want to interfere with the separation of powers.
  2. The courts choose to refrain from adjudicating the matter due to prudential concerns.

For example, the Supreme Court may consider a dispute between the President and Congress over war powers to be a political question. This is because the Constitution grants the President the power to make decisions related to national security, while Congress has the power to declare war. Therefore, the Supreme Court may choose not to intervene in such a dispute and leave it to the political process to resolve.

policyholder | Political Question Doctrine

General

General chat about the legal profession.
main_chatroom
👍 Chat vibe: 0 👎
Help us make LSD better!
Tell us what's important to you
manifestmoreadmissions
21:19
i wish i were competent so bad
manifestmoreadmissions
21:20
but that makes sense ty
KnowledgeableRitzyWasp
21:23
lmao me2
KnowledgeableRitzyWasp
21:24
let me know if you figure out how to be competent i would like tips
Hi! I’m a rising 3L at GULC who transferred and is in big law now. Does anyone have any questions lol
22:53
can you put a good word in for me with adcommns?
@georgiapeach88: Where did you transfer from? And why did you transfer?
Oh, I see from your profile: Maryland. Still, why did you transfer?
[] ararara
23:38
Caught the most epic sunset haha I was so high up my ears still haven’t popped
[] ararara
23:38
@georgiapeach88: I actually remember you from some of the first times I was on this site
Just out of curiosity: Do we think it's fair to say that the percentage of users of those site who continue to use it after their 1L starts, for those users who actually went or go to law school, is <1%?
manifestmoreadmissions
11:44
@georgiapeach88: not sure if you're still there but im also curious bout why you transferred, especially since your application says you were eventually admitted to GULC off the waitlist?
BelligerentMagicalWarthog
13:35
do we think GULC is done
KnowledgeableRitzyWasp
17:45
@BelligerentMagicalWarthog: last year they were accepting people off the waitlist from mid june up to a few days before classes start. so just off that and vibes I don't think they're done
Hi Guys
23:06
gulc said they'll get back to me by the week of june 17th
23:06
i hope they give me the a or r. i just want an answer 😭😭
has anyone on GW waitlist heard anything?
KnowledgeableRitzyWasp
23:55
@menherachan: praying for your WL A
0:13
@menherachan: i hope they give u that A as well
tysm! i hope so too lol
Hello everyone. Is it easy to miss important information about your admissions results if you don’t add your law school admission office to your Gmail contact? Did you find any important email from law school in your junk mail?
finna make yo hard times look pretty 😪
i watch my grandpa say penis
hys students when they see the above the law rankings 😪
@BelligerentMagicalWarthog: anecdote but a friend of mine got off the gulc waitlist in July last year
Write a poem rizzing up the admission staff
@Zenaida-Macroura: I got a waitlist on Saturday
Should I email HLS and ask if WL students get merch. They asked for my address for a surprise gift but I haven’t gotten anything
LSD+ is ad-free, with DMs, discounts, case briefs & more.