Warning

Info

Warning

Info

Warning

Info

LSDefine

Simple English definitions for legal terms

but-for test

Read a random definition: right to choose

A quick definition of but-for test:

The but-for test is a way to figure out if something caused something else to happen. It asks, "Would this thing have happened if that thing didn't exist?" This test is used in law to decide if someone is responsible for something bad that happened. But sometimes it's hard to know for sure if something caused something else, or if there were too many things that caused it. Courts have come up with different ways to solve these problems, like requiring more than just but-for cause to hold someone responsible, or using different tests to decide if someone caused something bad to happen.

A more thorough explanation:

The but-for test is a legal test used in both tort law and criminal law to determine actual causation. It asks the question, "but for the existence of X, would Y have occurred?"

In tort law, but-for causation is a requirement for liability in combination with proximate cause. If either of these is absent, a party cannot be held liable.

However, the but-for test has some problems. For example, it can be difficult to determine the cause of an event when there are multiple contributing factors. Additionally, the test can be too broad, making it possible to attribute liability to parties who are only tangentially related to an event.

To address these issues, courts have developed various approaches. In tort law, proximate cause is required in addition to but-for causation. In criminal law, courts may use the substantial factor test, the likelihood of survival test, the acceleration theory, the doctrine of proximate cause, or the Model Penal Code approach.

For example, under the substantial factor test, if two people shoot someone at the same time, both gunmen would be found guilty despite ambiguity about whose bullet caused the death. However, this test can also lead to problems, such as holding members of a firing squad liable even if their bullets did not harm the victim.

Overall, the but-for test is an important tool in determining causation in legal cases, but it must be used carefully and in conjunction with other legal principles.

but-for cause | buy-sell agreement

Warning

Info

General

General chat about the legal profession.
main_chatroom
👍 Chat vibe: 0 👎
Help us make LSD better!
Tell us what's important to you
18:14
Notre Dame is crushing my soul
18:14
So excited every Friday
NosyBeagle
18:20
i talked to such a nice rep for penn dick like years ago and i put them on my list
NosyBeagle
18:20
God bless that lady
Mostlylegal
18:34
Legit makes no sense that nd has accepted literally nobody still
18:35
manybe ND is taking a sabbatical?
got a gw wl->A!!!
NosyBeagle
18:46
yay! congrats
nice kiwi!!!!!
is that your first a?! :D
yes it is!! thanks guys
ugh so stoked for you
Did they give you scholly information???\
yeah they gave me 150k!
(not gendered) girl CONGRATS
you gonna go? :D
yeah I think so!! my goal was either nyc or dc so im super happy w it
so stoked for you. congrats. i imagine your previous decisions had been a little crushing. very happy your app got the recognition it deserved
18:55
@RoyalReadyKiwi: lessgo stay winning :D awesome work!!!
thank you so much guys!!! means a lot :D
CONGRATS ROYAL YASSSS
i feel like i live in my bubble because i'm seeing people talk about other people abusing time accommodations for the lsat and my first reaction was "they are?"
ronniedoeslaw
20:14
Congrats Kiwi!!
ParallelAgreeableOrangutan
20:35
@JupitersMoons: wait is email not typical for LOCI? ik you can upload to portals but isn't an email... a letter? an electronic mail?
ParallelAgreeableOrangutan
20:36
@RoyalReadyKiwi: congrats on your A! and your scholarship!!
MrThickRopes
21:11
Uhh
MrThickRopes
21:11
Yeaaah
MrThickRopes
21:11
Call me chairman of the federal reserve the way i print dat money
MrThickRopes
21:11
Call me Pooh bear da way i get dat honey
MrThickRopes
21:12
Call me Danny d da way I’m always sunny
LSD+ is ad-free, with DMs, discounts, case briefs & more.