Warning

Info

Warning

Info

Warning

Info

LSDefine

Simple English definitions for legal terms

best evidence rule

Read a random definition: prohibit

A quick definition of best evidence rule:

The best evidence rule is a legal principle that applies when someone wants to use a document, recording, or photo as evidence in court, but the original is not available. If the original is lost or destroyed, the person must explain why. If the reason is acceptable, they can use a copy of the document instead. However, this rule only applies when someone wants to prove what the document says, not just that it exists. Copies of documents are usually allowed in court, but if someone questions their authenticity, the original must be produced.

A more thorough explanation:

The best evidence rule is a legal principle that applies when a party wants to use a writing, recording, or photograph as evidence in a trial, but the original is not available. In such cases, the party must provide a valid reason why the original is not available. If the court finds the reason acceptable, the party can use secondary evidence to prove the contents of the document.

The best evidence rule only applies when a party seeks to prove the contents of the document sought to be admitted as evidence. For example, if a witness testifies that they made a payment without entering a receipt for the payment into evidence, the best evidence rule does not require the receipt to be entered.

Most information is stored electronically these days, so the original of an electronically stored piece of evidence includes an archive or printout of that information. For instance, if a party would like to enter a series of emails into evidence, they can print out the emails and use the printout as an original for satisfying the best evidence rule.

Duplicates of written, recorded, or photographic evidence are also admissible in court unless a genuine question is raised about the authenticity of the original or it is unfair to admit the duplicates due to the specific circumstances. For example, a party can enter a copy of a lease contract in a landlord-tenant dispute. However, if the opposing party claims that the copy of the lease contract provided is fraudulent, the best evidence rule requires that the original lease contract must be produced in such a scenario.

Whether a proponent has met the requirement for “admitting other evidence of the content of a document” is determined by the court. In a jury trial, however, the jury determines whether an asserted writing, recording, or photograph ever existed, whether another writing, recording, or photograph produced at trial is the original, or whether other evidence of content correctly reflects the content.

Berne Convention | best interests of the child

Warning

Info

General

General chat about the legal profession.
main_chatroom
👍 Chat vibe: 0 👎
Help us make LSD better!
Tell us what's important to you
11:19
I have a confession.
11:20
I am not a llama, and I am an adcommie @ The University of American Samoa Law (go LandCrabies)
12:01
I need a law school ranking based on which have reverse weave champion hoodies with the law school logo
I'm really sad it came to this.. but what are some law schools that will accept people with misconduct and irregularity of faking a transcript from lsac
I guess or from doing crimes too for that matter
yo how to delete messages
MrThickRopes
15:24
We walk in da graduation to day
MrThickRopes
15:25
That’s a lie we walk in it yesterday
MrThickRopes
15:26
Or maybe we walk in da graduation tomorrow
yeaaahhh
MrThickRopes
15:28
Yeah
MrThickRopes
15:28
Uhh
MrThickRopes
15:28
Yeah
MrThickRopes
15:28
Put dat beat on
MrThickRopes
20:27
I said PUT DA BEAT ON
20:31
mustard on da beat ho
22:14
im a slut for horse butt, #8 makes me feel great, horween makes my whore scream
22:20
catch me with this when I make partner
22:22
😍
22:24
Worth it
MrThickRopes
22:24
Uhhh
MrThickRopes
22:24
Yeaaah
MrThickRopes
22:25
Wake up in the morning gotta take a shit hop up in my lambo gotta take a shit headin to da club and i gotta take a shit poppin da champagne but i ruined it with shit
22:27
Woke up in the morning gotta thank god i dunno but today seems kinda odd no barking from the dog no smog mama cooked a breakfast with no hog i got my grub on but didn’t pig out finally got a call from a girl i wanna dig out
MrThickRopes
22:42
Wake up in the morning and i take a shit take off my pants cause they caked in shit go to da club and I’m finna get lit light up the blunt but it’s soaked in shit thrown on da curb because i took a shiiit
2:37
I fear you guys are not nearly locked-in enough
Why $0 at Harvard just to do litigation? Are you actually going to do your original plan post grad? @UncleIroh
LSD+ is ad-free, with DMs, discounts, case briefs & more.