Warning

Info

Warning

Info

Warning

Info

LSDefine

Simple English definitions for legal terms

constitutional avoidance

Read a random definition: security grade

A quick definition of constitutional avoidance:

Constitutional avoidance is when the Supreme Court tries to avoid making decisions about the Constitution if they can. Instead, they try to solve cases using other laws. This means that if there are two ways to understand a law, and one way is clearly okay with the Constitution, while the other way might not be, the Supreme Court will choose the way that is okay with the Constitution. This is to avoid having to make hard decisions about the Constitution. For example, in one case, the Supreme Court said that a law that said people had to have a jury trial for breaking a court order only applied to criminal cases, not civil cases. This was because having a jury trial for civil cases might not be okay with the Constitution.

A more thorough explanation:

Constitutional avoidance is a legal principle that suggests that the Supreme Court should avoid ruling on constitutional issues if possible. Instead, they should try to resolve cases based on other grounds, such as statutory interpretation.

For example, if the Supreme Court is faced with two possible interpretations of a law, one of which is clearly constitutional and the other of which is questionable, the court will choose the interpretation that is constitutional to avoid having to make a difficult constitutional decision.

One example of constitutional avoidance is the case of Michaelson et al v. United States ex rel. Chicago. In this case, the court interpreted the Clayton Act's requirement of a jury trial for contempt of court charges to apply only to criminal contempt charges. This was because legislation mandating jury trials for civil contempt of court raises constitutional questions.

Another example of constitutional avoidance is the case of National Federation of Independent Business v. Sebelius. In this case, the Supreme Court upheld the Affordable Care Act's individual mandate as a tax, rather than as a regulation of interstate commerce. This allowed the court to avoid ruling on the constitutionality of the individual mandate under the Commerce Clause.

These examples illustrate how the Supreme Court uses constitutional avoidance to avoid making difficult constitutional decisions. Instead, they try to resolve cases based on other grounds, such as statutory interpretation or tax law.

constitutional amendment | constitutional clauses

Warning

Info

General

General chat about the legal profession.
main_chatroom
👍 Chat vibe: 0 👎
Help us make LSD better!
Tell us what's important to you
on letterboxd ill follow u
12:47
Nemo_Propheta
but no judgement im a newbie film queen if u can even call it that
ok slay new follower for u
12:48
ty <3
12:49
omg i love talking heads
what is talking heads
@legallybrunettelily: shutter island is my favorite movie, lmfao
IT WAS GOOD BUT WHY IS IT SO LONG
i like foreplay what can I say
we know u like the princess kisses
ur so right
12:56
Talking Heads is a band, led by David Byrne
oh my username is truly just hoziers hyphenated last name
no ties to talking heads but i WILL look into it
12:56
Fake fan
im sorry queen
12:57
Watch their concert film Stop Making Sense
Nemo I love ur reviews
"bout to take the absolute wrong lesson from this with me into 2025 🙏" Nemo's review of Whiplash
NosyBeagle
12:59
don't you just love making a movie you're whole personality for a few weeks
NosyBeagle
12:59
I saw sinners with my mom on sunday
13:00
What can I say I write banger reviews, if only they got likes
13:05
I wrote one review that was so popular im still farming likes and followers off of it
13:10
damn i wish i was you
13:11
The secret is u gotta get in there early
13:14
I guess I just gotta go to the fests then
13:14
Or have friends that like ur shit
who up scheduling their optometrist appt
@legallybrunettelily: if that's ur bonafide selfie on letterboxd... awooga
LSD+ is ad-free, with DMs, discounts, case briefs & more.